All Notes
Note Transportation

The Pennsylvanian Doubles Its Service, Not Its Speed

By Austin Foster  ·  2 min read

Starting November 18, Amtrak's Pennsylvanian will run twice a day between Pittsburgh and New York instead of once. The trip still takes about 9 hours 25 minutes. What changes is the timetable: a new 1:00 PM departure from Pittsburgh joins the morning train, which moves from 7:30 to 7:10 AM, and a new 12:25 PM departure from New York joins the existing morning train.

That matters more than it sounds. With one train a day, the line only works if your plans fit its schedule. With two, people can start fitting the train into their plans: a same-day Pittsburgh to Harrisburg trip, a return on your own timing, a backup if you miss the first one.

The hard part wasn't buying trains. Norfolk Southern owns the track between Pittsburgh and Harrisburg, and a 2020 study found a second passenger train would cause unacceptable freight delays without major upgrades. PennDOT committed more than $80 million for passing sidings, interlockings and added mainline track, and a $143 million Federal Railroad Administration grant followed in December 2023. Together that is more than $223 million to add one round trip. Most intercity rail expansion in the US depends on this kind of deal with the host railroad.

Comparison of Amtrak's Pennsylvanian and nonstop flights between Pittsburgh and New York. One-way fares are similar: $78 to $136 by train, $60 to $165 by plane plus bags and airport transfers. Door to door, the train takes about 9.5 hours versus about 4 to 5 hours flying. The train runs 2 daily trips each way starting November 18; there are about 40 daily nonstop flights. The train serves 7 intermediate stops; flights serve none.
Fares are November 2026 snapshots from Wanderu, Momondo and Google Flights and change daily. Flying door-to-door time is an estimate that includes airport access and security.

For Pittsburgh to New York, flying still wins on speed and flexibility. Fares are about the same: train tickets start around $78 and average about $136 one way, while nonstop flights run roughly $60 to $165 before bag fees and the ride into Manhattan. But a nonstop takes about 1 hour 23 minutes in the air, and there are around 40 a day.

The bigger story is the towns in between. Greensburg, Latrobe, Johnstown and Altoona have little or no commercial air service to New York or Philadelphia, and the nearest alternative usually means a long drive. For those communities, a second train is a meaningful new option, not a slower version of a flight.

One limitation: checked bags and bikes are only accepted on Trains 42 and 45, so the new afternoon train out of Pittsburgh is carry-on only.

Why it matters: Frequency is what turns a train into something people can plan around. For the small cities along this line, two trains a day means the difference between a train you work around and one that works for you.

Sources: PennDOT; Travelers Today; Railway Age; Amtrak; Wanderu; Momondo; Google Flights.